Facilities managers select security providers by defining the site requirement first, checking that shortlisted firms meet legal and contractual minimums, scoring each bid against weighted criteria agreed in advance, and testing the provider’s mobilisation and management plan before award. Price matters, but it is weighed against evidence that the provider can staff, supervise and report on the contract consistently.
Read moreShow less
This guide describes a selection process that works for a single building or a portfolio, and the questions that tend to separate a dependable provider from one that only looks good on paper. For a shorter overview aimed at any buyer, see how to choose a security company.
Key takeaways
- Define the outcome and the site requirements before approaching the market, or bids will not be comparable.
- Due diligence should cover SIA approval, licence checks, screening, insurance, health and safety, subcontracting and financial stability.
- A weighted scoring matrix agreed in advance keeps the decision objective and defensible.
- Price should be tested against pay rates and on-costs, because a price that cannot support lawful pay will not deliver a stable service.
- Mobilisation, supervision and reporting deserve as much scrutiny as the headline rate.

Step 1: Define what the site actually needs
Most selection problems start with a vague requirement.
Read moreShow less
Before speaking to providers, agree internally:
- The outcome. For example, controlled access to a multi-tenant office, deterrence of trespass on a vacant floor, or out-of-hours alarm response.
- The posts and hours. Reception security on weekdays, a night patrol officer, weekend mobile patrols, or a combination.
- The tasks. Visitor management, key control, patrol routes, CCTV monitoring, lock-up checks, fire alarm duties, contractor permits.
- The systems. Access control, CCTV, intruder alarms, radios and any reporting platform the client already uses.
- The constraints. Tenant lease obligations, insurer requirements, building rules and budget.
If the requirement is not yet clear, a site survey by two or three providers can help, but the client should still own the final specification. Our article on what to include in a security tender sets out a full specification structure.
Step 2: Set minimum requirements (pass or fail)
Some criteria should be pass or fail rather than scored.
Read moreShow less
A provider that does not meet them should not progress, regardless of price.
| Minimum requirement | How to check it |
|---|---|
| SIA front-line licences for every officer deployed on licensable duties | Ask for the licensing process and spot-check licences on the SIA public register |
| SIA approved contractor status, if the client requires it | Search the SIA register of approved contractors and note the approved activities and expiry date |
| Employee screening | Ask how screening is carried out and whether it follows BS 7858; request a sample screening file structure (not personal data) |
| Insurance | Request certificates for employer’s liability, public liability and any professional indemnity cover required by the contract |
| Health and safety management | Request the health and safety policy, risk assessment approach and lone working arrangements |
| Data protection | Ask how incident data, CCTV and visitor records are handled under UK GDPR |
| Company standing | Check Companies House for status, filing history and officers |
The SIA approved contractor scheme is voluntary, but GOV.UK describes it as a quality hallmark, with approved companies assessed against a published standard. Buyers should check which activities a company is approved for: approval in one activity does not extend to others. The SIA also notes that buyers can ask a contractor for permission to see its assessment report.
BS 7858 is the British Standard for security screening of individuals employed in a secure environment. It sets out checks on identity, employment history and other areas. It is worth asking how a provider’s screening compares with it, while recognising that providers may describe their screening in different ways.
Step 3: Agree scoring criteria and weightings before bids arrive
A weighted matrix keeps the decision objective.
Read moreShow less
Agree it with stakeholders before reading any bids. A typical structure for a facilities contract might look like this:
| Criterion | What to look for | Example weighting |
|---|---|---|
| Understanding of the site | Specific risks identified; tailored post descriptions; realistic patrol plans | 15% |
| Staffing and supervision | Recruitment, training, relief cover, supervisor visits, out-of-hours management | 20% |
| Mobilisation | Named lead, timeline, TUPE handling, induction, assignment instructions | 15% |
| Reporting and technology | Patrol recording, incident reports, monthly reviews, escalation routes | 15% |
| Commercial | Transparent pricing schedule, pay rates, assumptions, indexation | 30% |
| Social value | Relevant, measurable commitments, if the organisation includes this | 5% |
These weightings are illustrative. Public bodies must follow their own procurement rules, which are covered in our tender article.
Step 4: Test the price, not just compare it
The lowest hourly rate is not necessarily the best value.
Read moreShow less
Security is labour-intensive, so most of the charge rate is pay and on-costs. Ask each bidder to break the rate down into:
- officer hourly pay and any premiums for nights, weekends and bank holidays;
- holiday pay, employer’s National Insurance and pension contributions;
- supervision, management and control room support;
- training, uniform, equipment and licensing support;
- overheads and margin.
From 1 April 2026, the National Living Wage for workers aged 21 and over is £12.71 per hour, according to GOV.UK. A charge rate that leaves too little above lawful pay once on-costs are added is a warning sign: it may mean unpaid breaks, excessive hours, high turnover or a provider that will seek a price increase soon after award. Our guide to security guard costs in the UK explains the main cost drivers.
Step 5: Ask questions that reveal how the service will run
Written bids can read well. Clarification meetings and site visits show whether the provider understands the work.
Read moreShow less
Useful questions include:
- Who will be our day-to-day contact, and who covers them when they are unavailable?
- How often will a supervisor or manager visit, and what do they check?
- How do you cover sickness or absence at short notice, and how do you make sure relief officers are inducted?
- What happens when an officer does not arrive for a shift? Who is alerted and how quickly?
- How do you record patrols and incidents, and what will we receive each day and each month?
- Will any part of the service be subcontracted? If so, to whom, and how do you manage them?
- How do you manage lone working for officers on night shifts?
HSE guidance makes clear that employers must manage health and safety risks before people work alone. A provider should be able to describe its lone worker monitoring in practical terms.
Step 6: Check references properly
Ask for references from clients with similar sites and ask referees specific questions: how quickly problems were resolved, how mobilisation went, how stable the officer team has been, and whether reports arrive on time.
Read moreShow less
A reference that only confirms that a contract exists adds little.
Step 7: Plan mobilisation before signing
Mobilisation is where many contracts succeed or fail.
Read moreShow less
Before award, agree:
- the start date and a mobilisation plan with named responsibilities;
- whether TUPE applies to incumbent officers, and the timetable for employee liability information and consultation;
- site inductions, assignment instructions and sign-off by the client;
- the handover of keys, codes and system access, with an audit trail;
- the first performance review date.
When a security contract moves from one provider to another, TUPE will often apply to the officers assigned to it. GOV.UK explains that a service provision change includes a contract ending and being given to a new contractor. Factor this into timelines and costs from the outset.
Step 8: Manage the contract after award
Selection does not end at signature. Agree a small number of key performance indicators, such as shift fill rate, patrol completion, report timeliness and complaint resolution, and review them monthly in the early months.
Read moreShow less
Use the reviews to adjust patrol routes, posts and hours as the site’s needs change.
Common mistakes to avoid
Read moreShow less
- Inviting bids against an unclear scope, then comparing prices that cover different services.
- Accepting a claim of SIA approval without checking which activities it covers.
- Choosing on rate alone without testing whether it supports lawful pay and adequate supervision.
- Ignoring TUPE until after award.
- Allowing assignment instructions to be written after the officers have started.
Working with Seccuro
Seccuro provides security guarding, reception security, mobile patrols, keyholding and CCTV services to facilities teams, available across the UK.
Read moreShow less
Client references are available on request. See our facilities management security page and security guarding service, or request a quote to start a conversation about your site.
Questions
How should quality and price be weighted?
There is no fixed rule. Many organisations give quality a greater weighting than price for security because failures can be costly.
Does TUPE apply when changing security provider?
Often, as Step 7 explains. Where it applies, the officers assigned to the contract may transfer to the new provider on their existing terms.
How many providers should be invited to bid?
Three to five is common for a single site or small portfolio. Fewer may limit competition; more increases evaluation effort without necessarily improving the outcome. Shortlisting against minimum requirements first keeps the process manageable.
Sources (5)Hide sources
- GOV.UK (SIA): Choosing an SIA approved contractor
- GOV.UK: Check security staff have a licence to work
- GOV.UK: National Minimum Wage and National Living Wage rates
- GOV.UK: Business transfers, takeovers and TUPE
- HSE, Lone working: protect those working alone
General guidance, not legal advice. Check current legislation and official guidance for your circumstances.